Part of the Live Finger Lakes networkExplore the region ›
A historic trolley passing under the Erie Railroad tracks in Hornell, New York
Photo: Unknown author · Public domain · Source

Hornell history: from Upper Canisteo to the Maple City

Hornell’s story is the railroad’s story, from the first Erie train in 1851 to the Acela trains built here today.

Upper Canisteo and Hornellsville

The area was first settled in 1790 as “Upper Canisteo,” to tell it apart from “Lower Canisteo” downriver. Benjamin Crosby’s family were the first settlers. The town was incorporated in 1820 as Hornellsville, named for George Hornell Jr., who built the first gristmill. It became a village in 1852, was chartered as the City of Hornellsville in 1888, and took the name Hornell in 1906.

The Erie Railroad

The New York and Erie Railroad reached Hornell in 1850 and began public service on May 14, 1851; President Millard Fillmore and Secretary of State Daniel Webster rode the inaugural train through town. Hornell was the junction of the Erie’s main line and its Buffalo line and the dividing point of two divisions, so the railroad built its repair shops here. For about a century the shops repaired engines for the whole Erie system.

Four rail lines once served Hornell, including a Lackawanna line toward Wayland and Geneva and an electric trolley, the Hornell Traction Company, that ran to North Hornell and Canisteo until 1926.

Floods, highways and change

  • Major flooding in 1936 put parts of the city under water and led to the levee system.
  • In 1950 Hornell had just over 15,000 residents, two radio stations (WWHG and WLEA) and three movie theaters.
  • Passenger rail ended by 1970. In 1972 Hurricane Agnes destroyed about 200 miles of roadbed along the Canisteo River.
  • The Route 36 arterial, built around 1972, cut through downtown and replaced Union Park.

Trains are still built here

The old Erie shops are now Alstom’s main North American assembly and manufacturing site, where railcars, traction motors and passenger locomotives are built, including Amtrak’s second-generation Acela trains.

Landmarks on the National Register

The Hornell Armory, Hornell Public Library, Adsit House, Lincoln School, St. Ann’s Federation Building and the U.S. Post Office are listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

See it for yourself

The restored Erie depot houses the Hornell Erie Depot Museum. The Hornell Public Library has local history and genealogy resources.

Sources and official links

Hours, fees and seasonal openings change. Always check the official page before you go. Spot something out of date? Tell us at Partner with us.

Around the valley

A Live Finger Lakes network site